Zillow partner teams

Speed is a staffing
problem.

A Zillow Preferred lead should get a live call attempt inside a minute, every hour you accept leads. Most teams already know that and still miss it, because they measure response time as a team average and staff coverage to the calendar instead of to the hours leads actually arrive. Rank response time per person, staff to the curve, give every lead one name and a timer, and read the numbers out loud once a week.

Written by Michael Schuerman, Strategic Partner in Atlanta. I was on the original team that brought Zillow Flex, now Preferred, to market, built the in-person partner training in Atlanta, and scaled it nationally. Updated September 2026.

Part of the Zillow Preferred guide for team owners. Preparing for 2027? Read the switching guide. Want help? Apply for a call.

01 The moves

Six moves, in this order

Measure response time per person, not per team

A team average hides the problem. One agent answering in forty seconds and three answering in nine minutes reads as a healthy average and converts like a bad one. Rank first-response time by person, last thirty days, and post it where the team can see it.

Cover the hours the leads actually arrive

Pull lead volume by hour and by day of week. In most teams the heaviest windows are weekday evenings and Saturday mornings, and those are exactly the windows staffed by whoever happens to be free. Staff coverage to the curve, not to the calendar you wish you had.

Give every lead one name before it arrives

Round robin without a backstop is a lead with no owner. Every lead needs a primary and a timer: if the primary has not connected inside the window, it moves. Written down, agreed to, enforced by the system and not by a group chat.

Answer with a call, then text, then keep going

First contact is a call attempt inside the window, a text immediately after if there is no answer, then a defined cadence for the next fourteen days. Most teams do the first two and quit on day three. The lead did not go cold, the follow-up did.

Watch appointments set versus appointments held

Fast response with a weak set is a vanity number. Track set and held separately per person. When held drops while set holds steady, the problem moved from speed to confirmation, and that is a different fix.

Read it out loud once a week

Response time, set, held, closed, per person, in a meeting where the numbers are said aloud. Everything on this page is available in your dashboard already. What is missing is the weekly moment where someone owns the number in front of peers.

02 Questions team owners ask

Speed, coverage, and what to hire

How fast should you respond to a Zillow lead?+

Inside a minute, with a live call attempt, every hour you accept leads. Speed matters because you are usually not the only agent the buyer contacted; the first real conversation frames the relationship. If you cannot answer in under a minute during your heaviest lead hours, fix coverage before you buy anything else.

Why does my team's response time look fine but conversion is bad?+

Because you are reading a team average. Averages hide the two or three people whose response times are minutes rather than seconds, and those people usually receive the same share of leads as everyone else. Rank first-response time per person over the last thirty days and the picture changes in ten minutes.

Should I hire an inside sales agent to answer leads?+

Only after you know your lead volume by hour and your response time by person. If the gap is a coverage gap in specific windows, coverage fixes it and is cheaper. If the gap is that nobody follows up past day three, an ISA with a defined cadence is a good hire. Hiring an ISA to compensate for an undefined standard just moves the standard problem to a new person.

What response time metrics should I track?+

Five: first-response time per person, connection rate, appointments set, appointments held, and closed transactions, all per person per week. Four of the five are activity you can change this week. Closings are the only one you cannot change directly, which is why they are the worst place to start a conversation.

Does faster response fix a bad conversion rate on its own?+

It fixes the top of it. Speed gets you the conversation; capacity, follow-up cadence, and the appointment-held rate decide whether that conversation becomes a transaction. Teams that only chase speed hit a new ceiling in about a quarter. The full sequence is on the Zillow conversions page.

Who fixes this, and what does it cost?+

I lead partner calls and expansion strategy, handle recruiting pitches, and provide VA support. The operating seat is scoped individually. Three-month minimum, then month to month. The first 30 days include a full diagnostic and plan.

03 The wider fix

Speed opens the door. It does not close it.

Response time is the first constraint, not the only one. Once you answer fast, the next ceilings are capacity per agent, the gap between appointments set and appointments held, and the follow-up nobody runs past day three. The full sequence lives on how to increase Zillow Preferred (Flex) conversions.

Next read

Scaling a Zillow Preferred (Flex) team

I was on the original team that brought Zillow Flex to market, built the Atlanta partner training, and scaled it nationally. That page covers what actually moves conversion on a partner team.

Read: Zillow Partner Teams

Bring your lead curve.

Lead volume by hour and response time per person for the last thirty days. I will tell you whether you have a speed problem or a coverage problem.

Not ready to book

Every month leads go unanswered has a number on it. The Funnel Check shows yours in about two minutes.

See what your lost leads cost you

Related