The hiring decision guide

Should I Hire a Sales Manager, a Coach, or a Strategic Partner?

Hire a sales manager when the play is written and needs running daily. Hire a coach when the play works and your people need skill reps. Hire a Strategic Partner when the decisions are stuck with you, revenue is flat, and nobody owns the numbers. Most owners hire a coach for a structural problem, then pay twice.

Written by Michael Schuerman, Strategic Partner in Atlanta. Twenty years building and running revenue teams, including the original Zillow Go-To-Market team that brought Flex, now Preferred, to market. Updated September 2026.

01 Five seats

What each hire actually fixes

A sales manager

Hire when: Your process works and you simply need more of it run daily.

Do not hire when: The process itself is undefined. A manager cannot manage a play that does not exist.

$90K to $160K base plus variable, full time, 60 to 90 days to hire and ramp.

A coach

Hire when: Your people know what to do and need skill, confidence, and accountability reps.

Do not hire when: The problem is routing, comp, capacity, or lead follow-up. Coaching a structural problem is expensive motivation.

Scoped individually, group or one to one, advice only. Nobody owns your numbers.

A consultant

Hire when: You need an outside diagnosis, a market read, or a document you can act on yourself.

Do not hire when: You already know what is wrong and nobody has time to execute it.

Scoped individually, ends at the deck.

A fractional COO

Hire when: Systems, reporting, and process are the gap and revenue is stable.

Do not hire when: Revenue is the gap. Most fractional COOs are operators, not revenue operators.

Scoped individually in the 2026 market.

A Strategic Partner

Hire when: The decisions are stuck with you, revenue is flat, and you need someone in the seat owning targets, people, and the weekly rhythm.

Do not hire when: You are under roughly $3M and the honest answer is that you need your first real closer, not a second leader.

Scoped individually. Three-month minimum, then month to month. The first step is a short application, followed by a 30-minute call if it's a fit.

02 The test

Three questions that pick the seat

  1. Can you name the standard? Response time, appointment count, weekly activity. If no one can state it, you need an owner, not a manager.
  2. Do your best people hit it and your others do not? That is a skill and accountability gap. A coach or a manager fits.
  3. Does nobody hit it consistently? That is structure: routing, capacity, comp, or hiring. That is the seat I take.

For real estate teams the same test runs on the funnel: why Zillow Preferred (Flex) leads stop converting is almost always speed and routing before it is skill.

03 Receipts

Where this has been run

  • Zillow: $0 to $300M in three years, launching Zillow Flex, now Zillow Preferred.
  • ChuckTown Homes: 10 producers to 90 in fifteen months, five markets, three states.
  • Dwelli: first Growth Advisor in the Flex program; owners Jake and Kelly Mullins grew the team to 180.
  • Built the sales team at a fitness company that reached $20M in revenue and was acquired by L.A. Fitness.

04 Questions owners ask

Hiring, cost, and fit

Should I hire a sales manager or a coach?+

Hire a sales manager when the play is written and it just needs running every day. Hire a coach when the play works and your people need reps and skill. If neither is true, meaning nobody can say what the standard is, what the number is, or who owns it, you do not have a manager problem or a coaching problem. You have an operating problem, and hiring either one will not fix it.

Who should I hire to help my agents perform better?+

Start with the diagnosis, not the title. If response time and appointment discipline are inconsistent, you need someone to own the funnel and the weekly rhythm. If the funnel is tight and conversion is still low, you need skill coaching. If your top producers are carrying everyone, you need a hiring and ramp system. Most teams hire a coach for a structural problem and pay for both.

I know I need help with my team but I do not know who to look for. Where do I start?+

Write down the three decisions that only you can make right now. If they are people decisions, you need a leader in the seat. If they are process decisions, you need an operator. If they are skill decisions, you need a coach. That list, plus your last 90 days of numbers, is exactly what the first call is built on. Thirty minutes.

Should I hire a Zillow Flex or Zillow Preferred coach?+

A coach helps if your agents hold appointments and simply need better conversations. Most Preferred teams losing allocation do not have that problem. They have a speed to first contact problem, a routing problem, or a capacity problem, and those are owned, not coached. I was one of 15 people on the original Zillow Go-To-Market team that brought Flex to market and spent two and a half years advising partner teams.

What is the difference between a Zillow coach and a Strategic Partner?+

A coach advises your people and leaves the results with you. A Strategic Partner takes the seat: the targets, the routing, the hiring calls, and the weekly meeting where the numbers get read out loud. Coaching is priced by scope and leaves execution with you. The operating seat is scoped individually. Three-month minimum, then month to month. Pick based on whether your problem is skill or structure.

Do I need a sales manager or a Strategic Partner first?+

If you can define the role, the standard, and the comp plan today, hire the sales manager. If you cannot, a Strategic Partner builds that first, then hires the manager into a seat that is already working. The order matters, because a manager hired into an undefined role usually leaves within a year and takes 90 days of momentum with them.

How much does each option cost?+

A full-time sales manager runs $90K to $160K base plus variable. A coach is priced by scope. A consulting project is priced by scope. A fractional COO is priced by scope in the 2026 market. The operating seat is scoped individually. Three-month minimum, then month to month. The first step is a short application, followed by a 30-minute call if it's a fit.

Is this only for real estate teams?+

No. Real estate is where the receipts are densest because of the Zillow years, but the seat is industry-neutral. The work is the same for a $12M home services company, a distributor, or a services firm: revenue targets, priorities, hiring calls, and the decisions currently stuck on the owner's calendar.

What results back this up?+

Zillow: $0 to $300M in three years, launching Zillow Flex, now Zillow Preferred. ChuckTown Homes: 10 producers to 90 across five markets and three states in fifteen months. Dwelli: Michael was their first Growth Advisor in the Flex program; owners Jake and Kelly Mullins grew the team to 180. Earlier, I built the sales team at a fitness company that reached $20M in revenue and was acquired by L.A. Fitness.

What happens on the first call?+

Thirty minutes. You bring the bottleneck and your last 90 days of numbers. I tell you which seat your problem actually calls for, including when the honest answer is a $70K coordinator instead of me. If the seat fits, we talk about what it looks like. If it does not, I tell you what does.

05 Go deeper

Read next

Not sure which seat.

Bring the bottleneck and your last 90 days. I will tell you which hire it calls for, even when it is not me.