For team owners buying Zillow leads
Switching from Market-Based Pricing to Zillow Preferred
If you've been buying Zillow leads upfront, Zillow Preferred changes how you pay and how you're measured. You stop paying for leads in advance. Instead, Zillow takes a success fee when a deal closes. And how many connections you get depends on how well your team performs. In November 2026, Zillow said it expects Preferred to handle 100% of buyer connections in the first half of 2027, up from about two-thirds in the third quarter of 2026. Here's what changes, what it does to your splits, and how to get through the first 90 days.
Written by Michael Schuerman, one of 15 people on the original Zillow Go-To-Market team that brought Flex to market. Last reviewed November 2026.
Part of the Zillow Preferred guide for team owners. Want help? Apply for a call.
What Zillow announced
Zillow says Preferred handled two-thirds of its buyer connections in the third quarter of 2026. It expects more than 75% by the end of 2026 and 100% in the first half of 2027. Partners pay Zillow when a deal closes, not before.
Zillow's announcement is about where its connections go. It doesn't promise that every team buying leads today will be invited or accepted. If your team depends on Zillow leads, plan for a performance-based program now and confirm your market's timing and terms with Zillow.
Confirmed vs. not confirmed
Plan around what Zillow has said publicly. Treat everything else as a question for your Zillow contact.
What Zillow has confirmed
- Preferred handled about two-thirds of buyer connections in the third quarter of 2026.
- Zillow expects more than 75% by the end of 2026.
- Zillow expects 100% of buyer connections to go through Preferred in the first half of 2027.
- Preferred partners pay a success fee when a deal closes, not for leads in advance.
What Zillow has not said
- That every Premier Agent team or agent buying leads today will be invited or accepted into Preferred.
- The exact date your market switches.
- What your success fee, starting volume or standards will be. Those depend on your market and agreement.
My recommendation—not an official Zillow policy—is to prepare to earn and maintain Preferred status through performance. Build the habits for meeting your agreed standards from day one, and confirm eligibility and continued participation requirements with Zillow.
01 What changes
What changes when you switch
You stop paying upfront. There's no cost per lead. You pay Zillow a success fee when a deal with a Zillow connection closes. Zillow's FAQ says fees currently range from 15% to 40% of the agent's commission, depending on the market.
You're graded every month. Zillow tracks things like how often your agents pick up connection calls, how many deals you close against a monthly target, and how fast you submit closing documents and pay invoices.
Volume follows performance. For your first three months, Zillow estimates your volume from your current Market-Based Pricing campaign. After that, it's based on how you perform against the standards compared with other teams in your market.
The tools are required. Every agent receiving Preferred connections needs a Follow Up Boss account with calling. New teams get 60 days from activation to get everyone set up. Every agent on the team also needs to be under the same brokerage and broker of record.
Zillow updates its terms, standards, and fees. Its own pages are the authoritative source. They're linked at the bottom of this guide.
02 The split math
What the success fee does to your splits
This is where most teams get surprised. Under Market-Based Pricing, you paid for leads before anyone closed. Under Preferred, Zillow is paid out of the commission. If your compensation plan was built for upfront lead costs, it probably doesn't work anymore.
Example: a $9,000 commission
| Success fee | Paid to Zillow | Left for the team and agent |
|---|---|---|
| 15% | $1,350 | $7,650 |
| 25% | $2,250 | $6,750 |
| 35% | $3,150 | $5,850 |
| 40% | $3,600 | $5,400 |
Compare it to what you pay today
Work out what each Zillow closing costs you now: take your monthly Market-Based Pricing spend and divide it by the number of Zillow deals you close in a month. Then compare that with the success fee on an average deal. Some teams will pay more per closing under Preferred, and some will pay less. Conversion is what decides it.
Questions to answer before you switch
- Does the fee come off the top before the team/agent split, or out of one side?
- Do agents on Zillow deals need a different split from agents working their own business?
- Who covers the Follow Up Boss cost?
- Will your best agents still want Zillow connections at the new split?
03 The standards
The standards your team is measured on
Zillow publishes its Preferred standards. Here's what they say as of October 2026, in plain English.
Team standards
- Buyer transaction target: Zillow gives your team a monthly target for buyer closings. The standard is to hit 100% or more of that target over the last six months.
- Zillow Home Loans pre-approvals: About 10% of your eligible connections that reached "met with" status in the last 90 days. The standard is 100% of that target over three months.
- Pay on time: 100% of success-fee invoices paid on time over three months.
- Closing documents: Valid closing documents submitted for 100% of closed deals over three months.
- Follow Up Boss coverage: 100% of participating agents on Follow Up Boss with calling, with their connections kept current.
Agent standards
- Predicted conversion rate: 4% or higher. This is Zillow's estimate of how an agent will perform, based on the last 180 days, with the last 90 counting more.
- Pickup rate: 25% or higher of connection calls answered over the last 90 days.
What happens if you slip
Zillow also gives each team a monthly health rating. One month below a minimum turns it yellow. Two months in a row turns it red, even if it's a different metric. A team that falls below the minimums or goes red enters a disengagement process. It typically has 30 days to fix the problem or it may be removed from the program.
04 The first 90 days
Your first 90 days
Your starting volume is borrowed from your old campaign. After three months, Zillow bases your volume on what your team actually does. Here's how to use that window.
Before you switch
- Keep your current campaign steady. Zillow's FAQ says cutting your Market-Based Pricing campaign before launch can lower your starting volume.
- Pay any outstanding balance. Zillow says overdue Market-Based Pricing balances can affect eligibility.
- Confirm every agent is under the same broker of record. Zillow requires it, with limited exceptions.
- Set up Follow Up Boss with calling for every agent. Don't use all 60 days.
- Update your compensation plan using the questions above, before the first deal closes.
- Decide your capacity and routing rules. Know which agents take which connections, and when.
- Have your team lead and transaction coordinator complete Zillow's required success-fee course.
Days 1 to 30: answer the phone
Pickup rate and speed are the first things to slip and the first things Zillow sees. Check pickup by agent every week. Keep Follow Up Boss updated every day, not on Fridays.
Days 31 to 60: turn connections into appointments
Track appointments set and met with by agent. This is also when the pre-approval target starts to matter, so make sure your agents introduce financing early.
Days 61 to 90: close and document
Compare closings against your buyer transaction target. Submit closing documents and pay invoices on time, every time. By day 90, you want a team that performs without you checking every number yourself.
05 Run it every week
Run the team to the standard every week
Teams that do well in a performance program don't wait for Zillow's monthly rating to find out how they're doing. They look at the same numbers themselves, every week, by agent.
- One weekly meeting, one page. Pickup rate, appointments set, appointments held, and closings against target, for each agent.
- One owner for each number. Someone other than you should own pickup and routing, and someone should own closing documents and invoices.
- Fix routing before you add agents. If connections go to agents who don't answer, more agents won't help. Send connections to the people who pick up.
- Coach to the stage that slipped. If appointments fell but conversations didn't, work on the conversation, not the lead source.
06 Who to hire first
Who to hire first
More connections without more capacity will hurt your numbers. Here's the usual order:
- ISA or lead manager if calls are coming in faster than your agents can pick up.
- Transaction coordinator before closing documents or invoices start slipping.
- More agents once response and follow-up are under control. Adding agents to a team that's already missing standards spreads the problem.
- Sales manager when agents know what to do but aren't doing it consistently.
07 Should you switch?
Should your team switch?
According to Zillow's FAQ for invited teams, once a market launches, all connections there go to Zillow Preferred partners. A team that declines the invitation stops receiving Zillow leads in that market, and leaving Preferred later doesn't mean going back to Market-Based Pricing. So for a team that depends on Zillow leads, the real question is whether you can meet the standards.
- Can your agents answer at least a quarter of connection calls?
- Do you know each agent's conversion rate today?
- Does your compensation plan still work after a 15% to 40% fee?
- Do you have enough agents for the volume you're asking for?
- Is someone other than you responsible for closing documents and invoices?
If you answered no to two or more of these, fix them before your launch date, not after.
2027 readiness checklist
- Ask your Zillow contact whether your team is eligible and when your market is scheduled.
- Pay any outstanding Market-Based Pricing balance.
- Confirm every agent is under the same brokerage and broker of record.
- Put every agent on Follow Up Boss with calling.
- Know each agent's pickup rate and conversion rate today.
- Rewrite your compensation plan for a success fee.
- Name who owns routing, closing documents and invoices.
- Start a weekly meeting on the numbers Zillow measures.
08 Proof
Owners I've worked with
"He never just told me what I wanted to hear. He provided honest feedback, thoughtful suggestions, and introduced me to different tools and systems that helped take my business to the next level."
"Within just 3 months of Michael's coaching and guidance, our team escalated to number 3 out of over 30 teams in the Orlando area."
"Michael architected a business game plan that opened my eyes to the possibility of expansion into new markets- new states- and many more sales people."
09 Questions owners ask
Questions about switching to Zillow Preferred
Will my Premier Agent team automatically qualify for Zillow Preferred?+
Zillow hasn't said that. Its November 2026 announcement is about where buyer connections will go: it expects Preferred to handle 100% of them in the first half of 2027. It doesn't say every team buying leads today will be invited or accepted. Zillow's Preferred FAQ describes participation by invitation, with eligibility tied to things like outstanding balances, brokerage setup and performance. Ask your Zillow contact whether your team is eligible and when your market is scheduled.
When does Zillow Preferred replace buying leads?+
Zillow says it expects Preferred to handle 100% of buyer connections in the first half of 2027. The timing in your market may differ, so check with your Zillow contact. Use the time before then to fix pickup rate, follow-up, splits and closing paperwork.
Is Zillow Preferred worth it for my team?+
Compare the cost of a closed deal, not the cost of a lead. Divide your current Zillow lead spend by the Zillow deals you close. Then compare that amount with the Preferred success fee for your ZIP codes and agreement. Next, calculate what remains for the team and agent after the fee and split. Check whether that covers the work each side pays for. A lower upfront bill does not tell you whether a closing is profitable. Before deciding, confirm your eligibility, launch terms, and current standards with Zillow. This guide is independent advice, not approval to join the program.
What is the difference between Market-Based Pricing and Zillow Preferred?+
With Market-Based Pricing, you pay Zillow upfront for leads. With Zillow Preferred, you pay nothing upfront and pay a success fee when a deal with a Zillow connection closes. Preferred teams also have to meet Zillow's published performance standards, and their connection volume depends on how they perform.
How much is the Zillow Preferred success fee?+
Zillow says success fees vary by market and currently range from 15% to 40% of the agent's commission. Zillow's Preferred pricing tool shows the fee by ZIP code.
Will I keep my current Zillow leads when I switch?+
According to Zillow's FAQ, your starting Preferred campaign is estimated from your current Market-Based Pricing campaign and any expansion ZIP codes you add, for your first three months. After that, your volume is based on how you perform against the standards compared with other teams in your market. Zillow notes that starting volumes are estimates, not guarantees.
What happens if I don't join Zillow Preferred?+
Zillow's FAQ says that once a market launches, all connections there go to Zillow Preferred partners. A team that declines stops receiving Zillow leads in that market.
What metrics does Zillow Preferred measure?+
As of October 2026, Zillow's published standards include a monthly buyer transaction target, a Zillow Home Loans pre-approval target, pay-on-time rate, closing document submission rate, and Follow Up Boss coverage for the team. Agents are measured on predicted conversion rate (4% or higher) and pickup rate (25% or higher).
Do all my agents need to be in my brokerage?+
Zillow says all agents on a Preferred team must be under the same brokerage and broker of record, with limited exceptions for situations like multi-state teams.
How should I change my agent splits for Zillow Preferred?+
Start by deciding whether the success fee comes off the top or out of one side of the split. Then check whether your best agents still want Zillow connections at the new numbers. Most teams that were built around paying for leads upfront need to redesign their compensation plan before the first closing, not after.
Who can help my team switch to Zillow Preferred?+
Zillow assigns Preferred teams a Growth Advisor for regular business reviews. Michael Schuerman is an independent Strategic Partner and former Zillow Growth Advisor Team Leader who works with team owners on the hiring, compensation, and sales performance the switch requires. He is not affiliated with Zillow.
Get ready before 2027
Bring me your current numbers: your monthly Zillow spend, closings, team size, and splits. If there's a fit, we'll talk about what needs to change before your launch date.
Related
- Zillow Preferred (Formerly Flex): A Team Owner's Guide From the Launch Team
- Zillow Preferred Leads Not Converting? 6 Causes to Check
- Help With Your Zillow Preferred Team: Who to Hire First
- How to Increase Zillow Preferred (Flex) Conversions
- How to Scale a Zillow Preferred (Flex) Team: Six Moves
- Zillow Lead Response Time: What Fast Actually Means
Sources
Last reviewed November 5, 2026. Zillow's terms and standards change; always check the current versions.
- Zillow, November 4, 2026: How Zillow is growing through one of the toughest housing markets in a generation
- Zillow Preferred FAQ
- Zillow Preferred Program Standards
- Zillow Preferred Compliance Policies
- Enroll in Zillow Preferred
- Zillow Q2 2026 earnings call (nearly all connections moving to Preferred over time)
Michael Schuerman is a former Zillow employee. This site is independent and not affiliated with or endorsed by Zillow Group.
Get an email when Zillow changes Preferred.
When Zillow changes Preferred standards, fees, or how connections are sent, I'll send a short note on what changed and what it means for your team. A few emails a year. Not a newsletter.