The symptom guide

Manager not managing.

Before you replace a sales manager, find out whether they were ever given the seat. Six checks settle it: was the role written down, is their own production bigger than the team's, is there a weekly rhythm with numbers read out loud, can they recruit without you, did the middle of the team improve, and would you rehire them today. Most of the time the seat was never defined, which is a two-week fix instead of a two-quarter one.

Written by Michael Schuerman, Strategic Partner in Atlanta. Twenty years building and running revenue teams, including $0 to $300M growing Zillow Flex, now Zillow Preferred, in three years. Updated September 2026.

01 The six tests

Run these before the conversation

Was the seat ever defined

Write down what the manager owns: the number, the headcount, the weekly rhythm, the hiring bar, the deals they are allowed to run. If you cannot write it in six lines, they were hired into a fog. That is your failure, not theirs, and it is the cheapest one to fix.

Are they managing or producing

Pull their personal production and their team's production side by side for the last 90 days. Most underperforming sales managers are strong closers being paid to close. If their own deals are the biggest line on the sheet, you do not have a manager, you have your best rep with a title.

Do they run a rhythm you can attend

There should be a weekly meeting with a fixed agenda, a one-on-one per person, and a number read out loud. Sit in one week without speaking. If the meeting is a status update instead of a decision, coaching is the fix.

Do they hire, or do you

A manager who cannot recruit is a manager whose team can only shrink. If you make every hire yourself, the seat is half filled no matter how good they are at the rest.

Do people get better under them

Rank each rep's production for the two quarters before this manager and the two quarters since. If the middle of the team is flat, coaching is not happening. Top reps improve on their own; the middle is the only honest scoreboard for a manager.

Would you rehire them today

Same salary, same market, knowing what you know. If the answer is no and it has been no for two quarters, you already made the decision. You are paying interest on it.

02 The decision

Coach, redefine, or replace

Coach when the rhythm exists and the standard exists but nobody is held to either. That is a habit problem. Six weeks of a fixed weekly meeting, one-on-ones, and a number read out loud fixes more managers than any hire you could make.

Redefine when they are your best closer with a title. Cap what they are allowed to run, pay them for the team number, or move them back to senior producer with the pay to match. Both of you will be relieved.

Replace when the seat was defined, the rhythm ran for two months, and the middle of the team is still flat. By then the decision makes itself and the team respects it, because they watched the standard exist first.

One rule I hold in every seat: do not replace a person to avoid redesigning a role. It costs you ninety days and buys you the same problem with a different name.

03 Questions owners ask

Managers, closers, and timing

How do I know if my sales manager is the problem?+

Run five checks: whether the seat was ever defined in writing, whether their personal production outweighs the team's, whether they run a weekly rhythm with numbers read out loud, whether they can recruit without you, and whether the middle of the team improved since they took over. The middle of the team is the honest scoreboard. Top producers improve on their own; a manager who cannot lift the middle three reps is not managing.

Should I fire my sales manager or coach them?+

Coach first if the role was never written down, if they have never had a manager themselves, or if they inherited a team they did not pick. Replace when you have defined the seat, run six to eight weeks of clear weekly expectations, and the middle of the team is still flat. Firing before the seat is defined usually buys you the same problem with a new name in ninety days.

My sales manager is my best closer. Is that a problem?+

Almost always. Every deal they close is a deal the team did not learn to close, and their comp usually rewards it. If their personal production is the largest line on your sheet, you are paying manager salary for rep output and getting neither the coaching nor the pipeline. Either move them back to a senior producer seat with the pay to match, or cap what they are allowed to run and hold them to the team number.

What should a sales manager own in an owner-led business?+

Six things: the team number, headcount and recruiting, the weekly meeting and one-on-ones, the standard for activity, the pipeline review, and the ramp plan for a new hire. If you own three of those six, you are still the sales manager and the person with the title is a coordinator.

How long before I judge a new sales manager?+

Activity and rhythm inside thirty days, pipeline shape inside sixty, closed revenue at one full sales cycle. Judge them on what they control first. If your average deal takes ninety days and you are calling it at month two on revenue, you are measuring luck.

Can you tell me which one it is?+

Yes, and it usually takes one call. Bring production per person for the last two quarters and the last three weekly meeting agendas. If you want it fixed rather than diagnosed, the operating seat is scoped individually Three-month minimum, then month to month. The first 30 days include a full diagnostic and plan.

Is it them or the seat.

Bring production per person for the last two quarters and your last three meeting agendas. I will tell you which one you have.

Not ready to book

Every month leads go unanswered has a number on it. The Funnel Check shows yours in about two minutes.

See what your lost leads cost you

Related